Martinez Closed Its Pickleball Courts While Centennial Set Distance Rules

  • Noise complaints have closed eight courts in Martinez, California, sent an HOA’s pickleball courts back to tennis in Allen, Texas, and landed in court in Delaware, Pennsylvania and Massachusetts, per The Pickleball Weekly.
  • Centennial, Colorado, bars permanent outdoor courts within 250 feet of homes, limits play to 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. and caps noise at 47 decibels at the nearest residential property line.
  • Quieter paddles and balls, sound barriers, careful court placement and shorter hours are the fixes that could help prevent the next dispute.

Noise Fights End In Closures, Conversions And Distance Rules

Eight outdoor pickleball courts opened at Hidden Valley Sports Courts in Martinez, California, in February 2025. In March 2026, the Martinez City Council voted to permanently discontinue pickleball at the site, just over a year after the courts opened. Nearby residents had complained about noise, traffic and parking. City officials tried restrictions and other measures, and the complaints continued.

The sound behind those complaints is the pop of a plastic ball off a hard paddle, repeated for hours. It is now a national fight. The Sports & Fitness Industry Association (SFIA) counts about 24.3 million Americans who played pickleball in 2025, up from 4.2 million in 2020. Communities, recreation centers and homeowners associations (HOAs) answered that growth by building courts or converting tennis courts, and more of those courts now sit in residential neighborhoods. Complaints about noise follow them there.

The cases below show how these disputes end: a council vote to close, a conversion back to tennis, a lawsuit, a judge’s order or a written rule on distance, hours and decibels. For a player or a club organizer, each ending points to what to fix before a neighbor files the first complaint.

Why Pickleball Noise Carries Into Nearby Homes

Pickleball uses hard paddles and lightweight plastic balls, and a rally produces sharp, repeated popping. To players, that sound is part of an afternoon of exercise, competition and socializing. To people who live nearby, it can run for several hours a day, and they say it interrupts conversations, work and relaxation.

Court builders cite acoustics data in these fights. Mor-Sports Group, an Estero, Florida, company that builds pickleball courts, states on its website that pickleball generates roughly 70 decibels on court and tennis roughly 40 to 45. In Boca Raton, Florida, court filings in a lawsuit against the Parkside at Boca Trail HOA say the association’s own acoustical study found that pickleball noise from the site exceeded the city’s daytime noise limits.

Many of the disputes in this story involve tennis courts that became pickleball courts. Communities have started to ask whether pickleball courts belong so close to people’s homes.

Martinez Closed Eight Courts Just Over A Year After They Opened

Martinez shows how fast a popular recreation project can turn into a neighborhood dispute. The courts opened in February 2025. The complaints started soon after and covered noise, traffic and parking. The city answered with restrictions and other measures. The complaints did not stop, and in March 2026 the City Council voted to end pickleball at the location for good.

Distance is part of the story. Some homes stood only 50 to 100 feet from the Hidden Valley courts. Centennial, Colorado, whose rules appear below, bars permanent outdoor courts within 250 feet of residential property. Against that line, the Martinez homes sat at two and a half to five times closer than Centennial allows.

The lesson for an organizer is that restrictions added after a complaint did not hold the courts open. Martinez tried them first, and the closure came anyway.

HOA Tennis Court Conversions In Allen And Alpharetta

In July 2024, the Twin Creeks HOA in Allen, Texas, converted two tennis courts into six pickleball courts. Homeowner Jeff Kacines says the courts stood about 350 feet from his window and that he regularly heard games throughout the day. After residents complained, the HOA converted the facilities back to tennis courts in 2026.

Kacines is still worried that a future HOA board could reverse the decision. He took the issue to the Allen City Council and is asking for clearer regulations on how close pickleball courts can sit to residential properties. The distance he describes, 350 feet, is farther than Centennial’s 250-foot ban. Under Centennial’s rules, a permanent court at that distance would need a permit and a noise assessment, which is a reminder that distance alone does not settle a complaint.

In Alpharetta, Georgia, residents of the Glen Abbey subdivision complained after their HOA converted tennis courts into pickleball courts. In a February 2026 television interview, homeowner Camie Christensen described hearing games in different rooms of her home. “We can’t escape,” Christensen said, explaining that the noise reached the family at meals and while family members worked. The complaints drew the attention of local officials, who considered additional regulations on the distance between pickleball courts and houses.

HOA fights are not limited to those two states. Homeowners in Palm Beach County, Florida, are suing their own associations over court noise. Richard Kitt, who lives about 70 feet from a court in his gated Boca Raton community, is the plaintiff against the Parkside HOA, which argues in court filings that it is permitted to change the makeup of its recreation center and that residents knew when they bought their homes that the complex could change. At Crescent Lakes, residents are circulating a recall petition against board members who approved converting a tennis court into pickleball courts.

Lawsuits In Lewes, Berwyn And Falmouth

The disputes have moved into courtrooms. In Lewes, Delaware, homeowners Michael and Patricia Katz took legal action against the Cape Shore HOA over pickleball on the neighborhood tennis courts. The Katzes argue that the noise interfered with their ability to enjoy their property, and they challenged the association’s responsibility to regulate disturbances.

A March 2024 Delaware Court of Chancery decision found that the Katzes’ complaint raised questions about the HOA’s rules, which prohibited excessive noise and activities that interfere with residents’ peaceful enjoyment of their property. The court allowed parts of the case to continue and dismissed the fiduciary-duty claim. The decision did not establish that pickleball is automatically a legal nuisance. It did show that a dispute over a recreational facility can grow into a complex legal fight.

Berwyn, Pennsylvania, shows the problem is not limited to HOAs. The Upper Main Line YMCA shut its outdoor pickleball courts amid a lawsuit from nearby homeowners, who raised concerns about noise and alleged zoning violations.

In Falmouth, Massachusetts, residents near the pickleball courts at the Lawrence School complained about the repeated noise, and in 2023 a Barnstable Superior Court judge ordered the courts temporarily closed. Resident Jon Churchill said he sometimes wore headphones outside to cope with the sound.

A complaint that starts with noise can end with lawyers, judges and a closed facility.

Centennial Sets Distance, Hours And Decibel Limits

Some communities have chosen rules over closures. Centennial, Colorado, adopted pickleball-specific regulations in September 2023, and the City of Centennial says they are meant to address noise while keeping pickleball in the community. The rules work in tiers:

  • Permanent outdoor courts, meaning courts with painted lines or tape or chalk lines that are not removed daily, are prohibited within 250 feet of residentially zoned or used properties.
  • A permanent court between 250 and 600 feet of residential property needs an Outdoor Pickleball Court Permit and noise mitigation under a Noise Impact Assessment.
  • Courts, including their lighting, can operate between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m.
  • Permanent courts can create no more than 47 decibels at the nearest residential property line.

Temporary courts, where the pickleball lines come off every day, face a 350-foot ban from residential property, with the same hours and the same 47-decibel limit. Courts that can prove they existed before March 21, 2023, are exempt from the distance rules but not from the hours or the decibel cap, and the city must confirm each one. Examples of evidence the city accepts for review are paid contractor invoices for the painted stripes and timestamped photos or security footage showing permanent lines, both dated before that day, together with written statements from neighbors and regular players. Statements that are not in writing do not count.

Centennial’s rules let courts exist inside limits instead of ending play. A club that plans a new outdoor court can read those numbers as a checklist: how far the court sits from the nearest house, what hours it runs and what the noise measures at the property line.

What Players And Organizers Can Do

Equipment is the first lever. USA Pickleball recognizes a category of quieter paddles, balls and accessories intended to reduce the sport’s acoustic impact. Mashpee, Massachusetts, shows what a required version looks like. Mashpee requires reduced-noise balls at its eight Ashumet Road courts from August. The first ball the town named, the Vortexball EVO Gen 2, costs $149 for a three-pack, about $50 a ball. After players objected to the price, the recreation department approved nine more reduced-noise balls at about $3 to $30 each, and only two of those are approved for USA Pickleball tournament play. More than 600 people signed a petition against the rule.

Barriers are the second lever. Mashpee put up sound-dampening fencing at its courts in 2020, and a town-commissioned study found that it helped. A second study in 2023, by professional sound consultants, recommended raising the fences further and switching to quieter equipment.

Placement is the third. Court builder Jeff McClure of Fast-Dry Courts says every residential court project starts with a plain discussion of available space, setbacks, drainage, lighting and proximity to neighbors. McClure speaks for a company that sells court construction, so weigh the advice with that in mind. A layout checklist for building a pickleball court covers drainage, lighting and surface along with layout.

Hours are the fourth. Reduced playing hours can help prevent conflicts, and Centennial’s 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. window, lighting included, is a working example.

Both Sides Have Something To Lose

For players, courts offer accessible places to stay active, meet new people and build community. Closing a facility removes recreation space that is in increasing demand. The SFIA numbers, 4.2 million players in 2020 and 24.3 million in 2025, show how fast the demand for that space has grown.

For homeowners, a quiet home is just as important, especially when courts go in near properties bought before pickleball boomed. The Katzes say the noise interfered with their enjoyment of their property, Kacines says he heard games throughout the day, and Christensen says the sound reached her family at meals and at work.

Where the courts sit, how many hours they run and whether both sides will compromise shape how each dispute ends.

Write The Rules Before The Complaint Arrives

The pickleball court wars are a planning problem that local governments and HOAs now have to solve while demand keeps rising. Martinez tried restrictions and then closed its courts. Centennial wrote distances, hours and a decibel limit into its rules and says they keep pickleball in the community.

For a club, an HOA board or a parks department, the practical sequence is short. Measure the distance from the court to the nearest home. Set the hours before the first game. Choose quieter equipment. Plan barriers and placement from the start.

George Howson

About George Howson

George Howson is a contributor to Racket Chronicle and an AIPS accredited journalist. An engineer and writer, he is known for asking direct questions and reporting plainly.

Leave a Comment